Optic neuritis — typical (demyelinating) vs atypical (NMOSD/MOGAD) neuro-ophthalmology lens
NEURO-OPHTHALMOLOGY-framed optic-neuritis depth engine — the definitive downstream of ophtho.acute-vision-loss.core.v1 (the breadth triage engine). Reciprocal bidirectional routing: triage sends ON cases here; this engine routes back if a competing acute cause (AION/CRAO/RD/AACG) is uncovered. The single hardest guardrail: IV methylprednisolone SPEEDS recovery but does NOT change final acuity, and standalone ORAL PREDNISONE IS CONTRAINDICATED in typical optic neuritis — it doubled recurrence vs placebo in the ONTT (Beck NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247); oral steroid is permissible ONLY as the post-IVMP taper. AQP4-NMOSD must NOT receive MS DMTs (can worsen disease). RxCUIs validated live against RxNav 2026-05-17 (GET https://rxnav.nlm.nih.gov/REST/rxcui.json?name=): methylprednisolone 6902, prednisone 8640, prednisolone 8638 — all RxNav-verified-live. Acetazolamide is clinically N/A to optic neuritis and is not used. Plasma exchange and chronic immunotherapy / DMT initiation are non_pharm / routed-out (owned by neuro.nmosd-mogad.core.v1 / neuro.multiple-sclerosis.core.v1). Chronic disease-modifying ownership is routed OUT by engine_id: MS DMT → neuro.multiple-sclerosis.core.v1; AQP4-NMOSD / relapsing-MOGAD chronic immunotherapy → neuro.nmosd-mogad.core.v1; arteritic-AION/GCA exclusion in the ≥50 patient → rheum.giant-cell-arteritis.core.v1; reciprocal triage → ophtho.acute-vision-loss.core.v1. Bayesian linkage (typical-demyelinating vs NMOSD vs MOGAD vs AION vs compressive pre-test priors by age/pain/laterality/disc/recovery; LR for pain-on-movement, RAPD, dyschromatopsia, MRI lesions, AQP4/MOG positivity; T_serology / T_PLEX / T_DMT decision thresholds; bidirectional cross-engine routing edges by engine_id) is documented in the co-located _design-brief.md + _research-bundle.md; first-class TS LR fields remain schema-blocked (same constraint as ophtho.acute-vision-loss.core.v1). Effect sizes (≥5): ONTT IVMP speeds recovery but 6-month/1-year acuity UNCHANGED vs placebo (Beck NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247 / Arch Ophthalmol 1993 PMID 8512477); standalone oral prednisone ~doubled recurrence vs placebo (relative risk ~2 — ONTT PMID 1734247); 15-year MS risk 25% with 0 baseline MRI lesions vs 72% with ≥1 (Beck Arch Neurol 2008 PMID 18541792); MOG-IgG ON ~80% multiphasic, annualised relapse rate ~0.92, functional blindness in ~36-70% (Jarius J Neuroinflammation 2016 PMID 27793206); plasma exchange ~42% moderate-marked improvement vs ~6% sham in steroid-refractory severe demyelinating attacks (Weinshenker Ann Neurol 1999 PMID 10589540) with ~76.5-83.3% objective response in refractory NMOSD apheresis (Zhang Ann Palliat Med 2021 PMID 33752428); all 11 evidence.pmids are real, PubMed-verified 2026-05-17.
Entry points (5)
- symptomSubacute monocular vision loss over hours-days WITH periocular pain worse on eye movement — the typical demyelinating optic-neuritis presentation (Beck ONTT NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247; Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757)subacute_monocular_vision_loss_with_eye_movement_pain
- symptomDisproportionate colour-vision loss (red desaturation) + central/cecocentral scotoma in one eye — optic-nerve dysfunction until excluded (Beck ONTT NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247; Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757)dyschromatopsia_with_central_scotoma
- symptomSevere (NLP/CF), bilateral simultaneous, painless, or non-recovering optic neuropathy — ATYPICAL: mandates AQP4/MOG serology + NMOSD/MOGAD/infectious/granulomatous workup (Wingerchuk Neurology 2015 PMID 26092914; Banwell Lancet Neurol 2023 PMID 36706773; Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757)severe_or_bilateral_or_painless_or_no_recovery_vision_loss
- historyKnown MS / NMOSD / MOGAD or recurrent optic neuritis presenting with a new attack — relapse entry; AQP4/MOG status reframes acute therapy and DMT (Wingerchuk Neurology 2015 PMID 26092914; Jarius J Neuroinflammation 2016 PMID 27793206)known_ms_nmosd_mogad_or_recurrent_optic_neuritis
- demographicOptic neuropathy at the age extremes — pediatric (MOGAD/ADEM-predominant) or ≥50 (atypical → exclude arteritic AION/GCA and compressive) (Banwell Lancet Neurol 2023 PMID 36706773; Liu Br J Ophthalmol 2018 PMID 30514710)pediatric_or_age_over_50_with_optic_neuropathy
Required inputs (17)
- pain_on_eye_movementrequiredsymptom • used at ENTRYPeriocular pain worse on eye movement is present in ~92% of typical demyelinating optic neuritis; painless severe loss is an atypical flag favouring AION/NMOSD/compressive (Beck ONTT NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247; Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757)
- laterality_and_simultaneityrequiredsymptom • used at ENTRYUnilateral favours typical demyelinating; bilateral SIMULTANEOUS severe loss is a strong atypical flag for NMOSD/MOGAD/toxic-nutritional/LHON and changes the workup (Wingerchuk Neurology 2015 PMID 26092914; Banwell Lancet Neurol 2023 PMID 36706773)
- visual_acuity_severity_nadirrequiredsymptom • used at CONTEXTProfound loss (no light perception / hand motions) and/or no recovery at the expected window are atypical — typical ON rarely goes to NLP and usually recovers; severe loss raises AQP4-NMOSD prior and the PLEX threshold (Beck Arch Ophthalmol 1993 PMID 8512477; Weinshenker Ann Neurol 1999 PMID 10589540)
- rapd_relative_afferent_pupillary_defectrequiredsymptom • used at INITIAL_WORKUPA RAPD localises the lesion to the unilateral/asymmetric optic nerve/retina and is the single most useful afferent bedside sign; its ABSENCE in claimed monocular loss argues functional or symmetric-bilateral disease (Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757)
- dyschromatopsia_red_desaturationrequiredsymptom • used at INITIAL_WORKUPColour-vision loss out of proportion to acuity is a hallmark of optic-nerve dysfunction and helps separate optic neuropathy from maculopathy/functional loss (Beck ONTT NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247)
- disc_appearancerequiredsymptom • used at INITIAL_WORKUPNormal disc (retrobulbar, ~2/3 of typical ON) vs mild papillitis vs SEVERE swelling with peripapillary haemorrhage/exudate (atypical — favours MOGAD perineuritis, AION, infiltration, papilloedema) reshapes the differential (Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757; Liu Br J Ophthalmol 2018 PMID 30514710)
- agerequireddemographic • used at CONTEXTTypical demyelinating ON is 15-50; pediatric skews MOGAD/ADEM; ≥50 with optic neuropathy must exclude arteritic AION/GCA and compressive lesions (atypical age) (Banwell Lancet Neurol 2023 PMID 36706773; Liu Br J Ophthalmol 2018 PMID 30514710)
- gca_symptom_cluster_if_age_over_50requiredsymptom • used at RED_FLAGS≥50 with new headache / jaw claudication / scalp tenderness / PMR mandates GCA exclusion (empiric steroid before biopsy, route OUT) because arteritic AION mimics ON in the older patient (route to rheum.giant-cell-arteritis.core.v1)
- demyelinating_or_autoimmune_historyrequiredhistory • used at CONTEXTPrior MS/NMOSD/MOGAD, prior optic neuritis, or systemic autoimmunity changes the pretest priors and the acute therapy (NMOSD → aggressive IVMP ± PLEX; MS → DMT decision) (Wingerchuk Neurology 2015 PMID 26092914; Jarius J Neuroinflammation 2016 PMID 27793206)
- infectious_granulomatous_paraneoplastic_exposurehistory • used at CONTEXTSyphilis/TB/Lyme/Bartonella/HIV, sarcoidosis, or a cancer history broaden an ATYPICAL optic neuropathy to infectious/granulomatous/paraneoplastic causes that need targeted serology/imaging before steroid (Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757)
- pregnancy_or_postpartumhistory • used at TREATMENTNMOSD relapse risk rises postpartum; steroid/PLEX and immunotherapy safety gating is pregnancy-dependent (Wingerchuk Neurology 2015 PMID 26092914)
- mri_brain_orbits_with_contrastrequiredimaging • used at BRANCHING_WORKUPGadolinium MRI brain + orbits: ON-segment enhancement/length pattern + brain white-matter lesions drive both diagnosis and the ONTT 15-year MS-risk stratification (0 lesions ~25% vs ≥1 lesion ~72% MS at 15 y) and therefore the DMT decision (Beck Arch Neurol 2008 PMID 18541792)
- aqp4_igg_serumlab • used at BRANCHING_WORKUPSerum AQP4-IgG (cell-based assay) confirms NMOSD — worse visual prognosis, do NOT use MS DMTs (can worsen NMOSD), needs aggressive acute therapy + chronic immunotherapy (Wingerchuk Neurology 2015 PMID 26092914)
- mog_igg_serumlab • used at BRANCHING_WORKUPSerum MOG-IgG (cell-based assay) confirms MOGAD — relapsing in ~80% (median time-to-relapse ~5 mo, ARR ~0.92), steroid-responsive but steroid-dependent, distinct chronic immunotherapy (Jarius J Neuroinflammation 2016 PMID 27793206; Banwell Lancet Neurol 2023 PMID 36706773)
- esr_crp_if_age_over_50lab • used at INITIAL_WORKUPIn the ≥50/atypical patient, ESR + CRP support or argue against arteritic AION/GCA; normal values never override empiric steroid if GCA is suspected (route to rheum.giant-cell-arteritis.core.v1)
- csf_analysislab • used at BRANCHING_WORKUPCSF (cells, protein, oligoclonal bands, infectious panel) supports MS risk (OCB+) and excludes infectious/granulomatous/neoplastic atypical optic neuropathy (Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757)
- creatininelab • used at TREATMENTRenal function for steroid-pulse comorbidity management and contrast-MRI safety in CKD (Inker NEJM 2021 race-free eGFR)
12-phase flow (12)
- 1FRAMEFrame this as a TYPICAL-vs-ATYPICAL optic-neuritis pivot, not a single disease. Typical = young, unilateral, painful, partial, normal/mildly swollen disc, demyelinating/MS-associated, ONTT-governed. Atypical (severe/NLP, bilateral simultaneous, painless, severe disc swelling/haemorrhage, no recovery, age extremes, recurrent) mandates AQP4/MOG serology + NMOSD/MOGAD/infectious/granulomatous/paraneoplastic workup. The hard guardrail set up here: IVMP speeds recovery but oral prednisone ALONE is contraindicated (ONTT — Beck NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247). Chronic disease ownership is routed OUT by engine_id.advance: typical/atypical framing set; ONTT oral-prednisone-alone guardrail foregrounded
- 2ENTRYRecognise the entry pattern: subacute monocular loss + pain-on-eye-movement + dyschromatopsia (typical triad), OR a severe/bilateral/painless/non-recovering optic neuropathy (atypical), OR a known-demyelinating relapse, OR an age-extreme presentation. Capture pain-on-movement and laterality/simultaneity up front (the first pivot binaries) (Beck ONTT NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247; Petzold Lancet Neurol 2022 PMID 36179757).inputs: pain_on_eye_movement, laterality_and_simultaneityactions: workup.acute_vision_lossadvance: entry pattern present; pain-on-movement + laterality/simultaneity recorded
- 3CONTEXTBuild the pretest priors: age (15-50 typical; pediatric MOGAD/ADEM; ≥50 atypical → exclude arteritic AION/GCA + compressive), visual-acuity nadir (profound loss is atypical and raises the AQP4-NMOSD prior), demyelinating/autoimmune history (NMOSD/MOGAD relapse reframes therapy), and infectious/granulomatous/paraneoplastic exposures. This phase assigns the typical-demyelinating vs NMOSD vs MOGAD vs AION vs compressive priors.inputs: visual_acuity_severity_nadir, age, demyelinating_or_autoimmune_history, infectious_granulomatous_paraneoplastic_exposureactions: workup.ms_flareadvance: typical-vs-atypical priors assigned by age × pain × laterality × severity × history
- 4RED_FLAGSCan-not-miss screen: (1) age ≥50 + GCA cluster (headache/jaw claudication/scalp tenderness/PMR) → arteritic AION mimics ON; empiric high-dose steroid then route to rheum.giant-cell-arteritis.core.v1, do NOT delay for ESR/biopsy; (2) bilateral severe simultaneous or rapidly sequential loss → NMOSD/MOGAD emergency aggressive IVMP ± early PLEX; (3) progressive painless loss with proptosis/optociliary shunt/headache → compressive or infiltrative — urgent neuro-imaging not steroid; (4) recent vaccination/infection in a child → MOGAD/ADEM. Recognised and started here; chronic ownership routed OUT.inputs: gca_symptom_cluster_if_age_over_50actions: workup.gca_temporal_arteritis, calc.news2advance: GCA, bilateral-severe NMOSD/MOGAD, compressive, and pediatric-MOGAD red flags screened and time-critical action initiated
- 5INITIAL_WORKUPBedside afferent exam: visual acuity each eye, RAPD (the key localiser; absent in functional/symmetric-bilateral), colour vision/red desaturation, confrontation + formal fields (central/cecocentral scotoma typical; altitudinal favours AION; bitemporal favours chiasmal/compressive), dilated fundus (normal retrobulbar ~2/3 vs mild papillitis vs SEVERE swelling/peripapillary haemorrhage = atypical). STAT ESR/CRP if ≥50 (GCA — never delays empiric steroid). CBC + inflammatory + metabolic baseline.inputs: rapd_relative_afferent_pupillary_defect, dyschromatopsia_red_desaturation, disc_appearance, esr_crp_if_age_over_50actions: workup.acute_red_eye, panel.cbc, panel.inflammation, panel.cmp, calc.nihssadvance: afferent exam + fields + fundus done; GCA inflammatory labs sent if ≥50
- 6BRANCHING_WORKUPGadolinium MRI brain + orbits is the pivotal test: optic-nerve enhancement length/location (long/posterior/chiasmal → NMOSD; long anterior + perineural/optic-sheath → MOGAD; short/anterior + ≥1 periventricular Dawson-finger white-matter lesion → typical MS-risk demyelinating) and the ONTT 15-year MS-risk stratification (0 lesions ~25% vs ≥1 lesion ~72% MS at 15 y — Beck Arch Neurol 2008 PMID 18541792). If ANY atypical feature: send serum AQP4-IgG + MOG-IgG (cell-based assay), CSF (cells/protein/OCB/infectious panel), and a targeted infectious/granulomatous/paraneoplastic panel (RPR-TPPA, ACE/CXR for sarcoid, Bartonella/TB/Lyme/HIV, paraneoplastic CRMP-5/anti-CV2 if indicated). Temporal-artery biopsy if GCA suspected (never gates steroid).inputs: mri_brain_orbits_with_contrast, aqp4_igg_serum, mog_igg_serum, csf_analysisactions: workup.ms_flare, workup.acute_headache, panel.csfadvance: MRI pattern + MS-risk band assigned; AQP4/MOG/CSF/infectious panel sent if atypical
- 7DIFFERENTIALTerminal differential with named pivot findings: TYPICAL demyelinating ON (young + unilateral + pain-on-movement + dyschromatopsia + RAPD + normal/mild disc + good recovery pivot) vs AQP4-NMOSD ON (severe/NLP + bilateral/recurrent + long posterior/chiasmal enhancement + AQP4-IgG+ + poor recovery pivot) vs MOGAD ON (severe but recovers + bilateral + SEVERE disc swelling/perineural enhancement + MOG-IgG+ + steroid-responsive/steroid-dependent + pediatric pivot) vs arteritic AION/GCA (≥50 + pallid disc edema + jaw claudication + ↑ESR/CRP/platelets pivot — route to rheum.giant-cell-arteritis.core.v1) vs non-arteritic AION (sudden painless + altitudinal field + small crowded "disc at risk" + vasculopath + normal ESR pivot) vs papilloedema (BILATERAL disc swelling + preserved acuity early + headache/pulsatile tinnitus + raised ICP pivot) vs CRAO/CRVO (retinal not optic-nerve fundus signs pivot — route to ophtho.acute-vision-loss.core.v1) vs compressive optic neuropathy (slowly progressive painless + optociliary shunt/proptosis + mass on MRI pivot) vs toxic/nutritional (bilateral painless symmetric + cecocentral + B12/folate/ethambutol/methanol pivot) vs LHON (young male + bilateral sequential painless + telangiectatic disc + mtDNA pivot) vs functional (normal RAPD/fundus/OCT/VEP + non-physiologic fields pivot — diagnosis of exclusion).advance: single best diagnosis selected; typical-vs-atypical pivot explicitly resolved; arteritic-AION pivot explicitly excluded if ≥50
- 8RISK_STRATIFICATIONStratify by (a) MS-conversion risk — ONTT MRI-lesion count drives the 15-year MS probability and the DMT discussion (0 lesions ~25% vs ≥1 ~72% — Beck Arch Neurol 2008 PMID 18541792); (b) attack severity — profound loss / bilateral / AQP4-positive NMOSD → aggressive IVMP + early-PLEX threshold (Weinshenker Ann Neurol 1999 PMID 10589540); (c) relapse risk — MOGAD/NMOSD seropositivity predicts a relapsing course needing chronic immunotherapy (Jarius J Neuroinflammation 2016 PMID 27793206). Systemic-instability overlay (NEWS2) for an unwell atypical/infectious presentation.inputs: mri_brain_orbits_with_contrast, visual_acuity_severity_nadiractions: calc.news2advance: MS-risk band + attack-severity tier + relapse-risk tier assigned
- 9TREATMENTONTT-governed, typical/atypical-stratified, route-OUT-after-acute: (1) Typical demyelinating ON → IV methylprednisolone 1 g/day × 3-5 d SPEEDS recovery but does NOT change final acuity; oral prednisone ALONE is CONTRAINDICATED (↑recurrence vs placebo — Beck ONTT NEJM 1992 PMID 1734247); steroid is optional (recovery occurs without it). (2) Post-IVMP oral prednisone TAPER is acceptable only as a taper, never as standalone therapy. (3) Severe / bilateral / AQP4-NMOSD / steroid-refractory attack → plasma exchange (Weinshenker Ann Neurol 1999 PMID 10589540; ~76-83% objective response in refractory NMOSD — Zhang Ann Palliat Med 2021 PMID 33752428). (4) MOGAD → steroid-responsive but steroid-dependent — slow taper, do NOT stop abruptly (Jarius J Neuroinflammation 2016 PMID 27793206). (5) Chronic immunotherapy / DMT initiation is NON-PHARM ROUTED — MS DMT via neuro.multiple-sclerosis.core.v1, AQP4/MOG chronic therapy via neuro.nmosd-mogad.core.v1 (do NOT start MS DMTs in AQP4-NMOSD — can worsen). Symptomatic: analgesia for movement pain. Pregnancy/renal gating applied.inputs: pregnancy_or_postpartum, creatinine, visual_acuity_severity_nadiradvance: acute therapy decided per typical/atypical (oral-prednisone-alone guardrail enforced); PLEX considered if severe/NMOSD; chronic ownership routed by engine_id
- 10DISPOSITIONTypical mild ON → outpatient with rapid neuro-ophthalmology + MRI; observation/IVMP infusion as needed. Severe / bilateral / NMOSD / steroid-refractory → admit for IVMP ± PLEX + urgent neurology/neuro-immunology. Atypical infectious/granulomatous/paraneoplastic → admit for targeted workup. ≥50 with GCA suspicion → admit, empiric steroid, route to rheum.giant-cell-arteritis.core.v1. Compressive lesion on MRI → urgent neurosurgery/ophthalmology. Functional vision loss → reassurance + outpatient neuro-ophthalmology after organic exclusion.inputs: visual_acuity_severity_nadiradvance: disposition + routed engine_id documented
- 11MONITORINGTypical ON: serial acuity/colour/fields — most recover useful acuity by months even WITHOUT steroid (ONTT — Beck Arch Ophthalmol 1993 PMID 8512477); IVMP only changes the speed. NMOSD/MOGAD: visual recovery is often worse and incomplete — vigilance for the next attack and the fellow eye (Jarius J Neuroinflammation 2016 PMID 27793206). Failure to recover at the expected window is itself an ATYPICAL flag → re-open the AQP4/MOG/infectious/compressive workup. Steroid-pulse monitoring (glucose, BP, mood, infection). ESR/CRP trend if GCA on steroid.inputs: visual_acuity_severity_nadiractions: panel.inflammationadvance: recovery trajectory tracked; non-recovery re-triggers atypical workup; steroid-pulse safety monitored
- 12FOLLOWUPThe long-tail deliverable is RISK-STRATIFIED DISEASE-MODIFYING ROUTING: (1) Typical ON + ≥1 MRI lesion → high 15-year MS risk → MS DMT discussion via neuro.multiple-sclerosis.core.v1 (Beck Arch Neurol 2008 PMID 18541792). (2) AQP4-NMOSD → lifelong chronic immunotherapy (rituximab/eculizumab/inebilizumab/satralizumab class — routed) and explicit MS-DMT avoidance via neuro.nmosd-mogad.core.v1 (Wingerchuk Neurology 2015 PMID 26092914). (3) MOGAD relapsing/steroid-dependent → chronic immunotherapy + slow steroid taper via neuro.nmosd-mogad.core.v1 (Banwell Lancet Neurol 2023 PMID 36706773). (4) Reciprocal handoff with ophtho.acute-vision-loss.core.v1 (the upstream triage engine). Low-vision rehabilitation for incomplete recovery; relapse-warning education.inputs: demyelinating_or_autoimmune_history, mri_brain_orbits_with_contrastadvance: MS-risk-stratified DMT / NMOSD-MOGAD chronic-immunotherapy ownership handed to the routed engine_id; reciprocal acute-vision-loss handoff documented